Secure by Design for AI: A Real-World Healthcare Case Study

Fifth and final in a five-part series on implementing Secure by Design principles in AI system development

Introduction

Throughout this blog series, we've explored the concept of Secure by Design principles for AI, from understanding the evolving threat landscape to implementing specialized tools and technologies. Let’s now take a look at this concept in action through a real-world case study that demonstrates how organizations can successfully apply these principles to meet rigorous security and compliance requirements.

The Challenge: Security and Compliance in Healthcare AI

A global healthcare diagnostics provider with over 2,000 patient centers faced a critical challenge: maintaining rigorous compliance with FDA and international regulations while advancing their GenAI applications used by clinicians daily.

The stakes were particularly high in this scenario. The company's AI systems were directly involved in patient care, meaning any security vulnerabilities could potentially impact health outcomes. Additionally, operating in the heavily regulated healthcare industry required adherence to strict compliance standards that weren't originally designed with generative AI in mind.

Their existing security infrastructure, while robust for traditional applications, proved insufficient for their emerging GenAI systems. The unique vulnerabilities and behaviors of large language models required specialized security approaches that traditional cybersecurity tools couldn't provide.

Regulatory Requirements and Compliance Needs

FDA Compliance and Good Machine Learning Practice

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates the safe use of AI in the healthcare field through various frameworks, including the Good Machine Learning Practice (GMLP) principles. These principles (several of which we've covered throughout this series) range from implementing good engineering and security practices to continuous model monitoring.

For this healthcare diagnostics provider, compliance requirements manifested in several critical areas:

1. Validating security between stakeholders: Ensuring that GenAI systems facilitating communication between clinicians and scientists maintained appropriate security and data protections
   
   
2. Maintaining compliance through updates: Preserving auditability and regulatory compliance as GenAI systems evolved through model updates and modifications
   
   
3. Adapting security testing: Modifying existing red teaming practices to address AI-specific vulnerabilities without clear standards-based guidance

These challenges highlighted a critical gap: traditional cybersecurity tools lacked the specialized capabilities needed to monitor, test, and secure the unique vulnerabilities of large language models operating in healthcare environments.

Implementing a Defense in Depth Strategy

To address these challenges, the healthcare diagnostics company implemented a comprehensive Defense in Depth strategy specifically designed for their GenAI applications. This approach aligned with the Secure by Design principles we've discussed throughout this series:

Taking Ownership of Security Outcomes

Rather than treating AI security as separate from their overall security program, the company integrated AI-specific controls into their broader security governance framework. This ensured clear accountability and ownership of security outcomes across the entire AI development lifecycle.

The strategy began with a thorough inventory of all AI models in use and under development, creating visibility that enabled proper risk assessment and prioritization. Security requirements were established early in the development process, ensuring that security was built in rather than bolted on.

Embracing Radical Transparency

The company implemented several key mechanisms to ensure transparency:

• Real-time LLM observability: Deploying continuous monitoring systems that tracked model outputs, behaviors, and potential drift, creating an audit trail for regulatory compliance
  
  
• Comprehensive documentation: Maintaining detailed records of model development, training data sources, and testing procedures
  
  
• Clear communication channels: Establishing protocols for reporting and addressing security concerns across clinical, technical, and compliance teams

Leading from the Top

Executive leadership championed the implementation of AI-specific security measures, allocating resources and establishing governance structures that prioritized both innovation and security. This top-down commitment ensured that security considerations weren't overshadowed by feature development or deployment timelines.

Key Security Controls and Their Impact

The healthcare diagnostics company implemented several specialized security controls as part of their Defense in Depth strategy.

Real-Time LLM Observability

The company deployed monitoring tools specifically designed for generative AI systems, providing:

• Continuous tracking of model inputs and outputs
• Analysis of response patterns to detect potential data leakage
• Identification of unusual behavior that might indicate security issues
• Comprehensive audit trails for regulatory compliance

This observability created a foundation for both security and compliance, allowing the company to demonstrate appropriate controls to regulators while quickly identifying potential security issues.

Automated Red Teaming

Recognizing the unique challenges of testing AI systems, the company implemented:

• Healthcare-specific attack simulations targeting their particular use cases
• Systematic testing of prompt injection, data extraction, and jailbreaking techniques
• Continuous validation of model guardrails and safety mechanisms
• Benchmarking against emerging industry standards and best practices

This proactive approach to security testing helped identify vulnerabilities before they could be exploited in production, significantly reducing risk while providing documentation for compliance purposes.

Rapid Response Mechanisms

The company established protocols for quickly addressing security issues when detected:

• Automated alerting for high-risk model behaviors
• Clear escalation paths for potential compliance violations
• Predefined rollback procedures for compromised models
• Incident response playbooks specific to AI security events

These mechanisms ensured that the company could detect and address compliance or security issues before patients were impacted, maintaining both safety and regulatory compliance.

Continuous Feedback Integration

The security program incorporated ongoing learning through:

• Regular reviews of security incidents and near-misses
• Integration of emerging threat intelligence specific to healthcare AI
• Collaborative sharing of security findings across development teams
• Periodic reassessment of security controls against evolving regulatory guidance

This commitment to continuous improvement allowed security measures to evolve alongside both the technology and the regulatory landscape.

Results and Business Impact

The end-to-end security approach enabled the healthcare diagnostics company to achieve several critical outcomes:

1. Regulatory compliance: The company successfully demonstrated compliance with FDA requirements and other applicable regulations, enabling continued deployment of AI technologies in patient care settings.
   
   
2. Accelerated innovation: By establishing clear security guardrails and testing procedures, development teams could innovate confidently, knowing that security controls would identify potential issues early.
   
   
3. Risk reduction: The comprehensive security approach significantly reduced the risk of data breaches, model manipulation, or other security incidents that could impact patient care.
   
   
4. Enhanced trust: Clinicians and patients gained confidence in the AI systems through transparent security practices and rigorous validation procedures.

Lessons Learned and Best Practices

This case study highlights several key lessons for organizations implementing Secure by Design principles for AI systems:

1. Integration is essential: Effective AI security must integrate with existing security frameworks while addressing AI-specific concerns.
   
   
2. Specialized tooling matters: Traditional security tools are insufficient for AI systems; purpose-built solutions for model monitoring, testing, and protection are necessary.
   
   
3. Process adaptation is required: Existing security processes need thoughtful adaptation to address the unique characteristics of AI systems.
   
   
4. Documentation drives compliance: Comprehensive documentation of security controls, testing procedures, and incident response protocols is essential for regulatory compliance.
   
   
5. Continuous improvement is non-negotiable: As both AI technology and the threat landscape evolve, security approaches must continuously adapt.

Conclusion: Secure by Design as a Competitive Advantage

For the healthcare diagnostics company, implementing Secure by Design principles for their AI systems wasn't just about compliance—it became a competitive advantage. By building robust security into their AI development lifecycle, they could confidently deploy advanced technologies that enhanced patient care while maintaining the highest standards of security and regulatory compliance.

This case study demonstrates that Secure by Design isn't just a theoretical framework—it's a practical approach that enables organizations to harness the power of AI while effectively managing risks. As AI continues to transform industries beyond healthcare, these principles will become increasingly essential for organizations seeking to build reliable, trustworthy, and secure AI systems.

By following the guidance outlined throughout this series and learning from real-world implementations like this case study, organizations across industries can develop AI systems that are not only powerful and innovative but also secure by design.

Thank you for following our five-part series on implementing Secure by Design principles in AI system development. For more information on securing your AI systems, visit protectai.com.

Ready to dive deeper? Get the full white paper: Securing AI’s Front Lines: Implementing Secure by Design Principles in AI System Development